Critical Thinking: Media and Democracy

A proposition has been put forward by Noam Chomsky concerning the relationship between the media and democracy. While Chomsky states that people are either willing or unwitting instruments of Governments, there is no need for this to be the case.

By applying principles of critical thinking, one can see beyond the indoctrination of “brainwashing by freedom” that Chomsky refers to. In particular, Facione (2010) refers to metacognition and self-regulation as skills that can be honed to check understanding the real meaning of what is being said, or what is written. Guillot (2004) also puts forward that critical thinking can be used to guide the outer dimensions of thinking. In light of the proposition that we are “indoctrinated”, a quote by Francis Bacon on the Air University website might also be considered: “The entry of truth with chalk to mark those minds which are capable to lodge and harbour it.”

A video on YouTube, Outfoxed (2Critical4U, 2009) puts forward the notion that Rupert Murdoch’s media empire is aligned with the US political right. It also puts forward that the reporting on Fox News is directly influenced by Murdoch and News Corp. Weir (2004) reported a lack of accurate reporting in the main US newspapers. Additionally, the video Reel Bad Arabs (Neversaidb4, 2008) looks at how Hollywood can portray an ethnic group consistently in a bad light, to influence public perception.

Weir (2004) went on to assume that this disparity is for the most part due to a public that chooses to close their eyes to the facts. Chomsky (1992) went even further on this issue of an innocent public freely accepting whatever the media tells them to. Barsamian (2002) advanced again that the media use subversion and control to manufacture consent to a seemingly willing public.

A discussion of recent news events illustrates how media can be used to either indoctrinate those that allow it to (Chomsky, 1992) or can be used to draw comparisons using metacognition (Facione, 2010).

A news story that seems to epitomise the points in question is Wikileaks founder Julian Assange, described by some as a villain (Hitchens, 2010), and by others as a man hounded unmercifully for telling the truth (Cameron, 2011). The two writers use differing styles, with Cameron (2011) using a more reasoned argument than Hitchens (2010) whose article is emotive and biased.

While both use emotion, they use it in different ways. Hitchens (2010, para 12) uses words such as “cunning”, “strategy” and “made everyone complicit” in an accusatory manner, as well as accusing Assange of living in a fantasy world (Hitchens, 2010, para 25). He also writes some support statements about Assange, but these are written in a neutral tone, such as denouncing the Swedish sex charges (Hitchens, 2010, para 19), almost just in passing.

At other times, Hitchens denounces those who support Assange, such as the New York Times (NYT) (Hitchens, 2010, para 26). The NYT called Wikileaks an anti-secrecy and whistle blowing outfit (Hitchens, 2010, para 25, which Hitchens (2010, para 27) attacked as “mush-headed approval” and called Wikileaks “his [Assange’s] little cabal” (Hitchens, 2010, para 26).

On the other hand, Cameron (2011, para 14) defends Assange against the attacks of some world leaders, including Australian Prime Minister Julia Gillard. Gillard asserted that Wikileaks was illegal, but did not say what law was broken (Cameron, 2011, para 12). The USA, as well, pursues Assange on shaky legal grounds for alleged crimes that seem to have insufficient substance to warrant the resources being over-utilised, claiming he must be hunted down like a terrorist (Cameron, 2011, para 14).

Hitchens (2010) is similar in tactics to the concepts verbally revealed in Outfoxed (2Critical4U, 2009) and written by Chomsky (2002) of manufacturing consent, that the media is influenced by the Government. Cameron, however, may be seen to take the public’s side to put forward debate on the issue, which Chomsky (2002) expressed concern that the public were unable to do.

The Wikileaks controversy makes us consider the extent to which we need protection from the truth (Cameron, 2010, para 5). It also puts in the spotlight how Governments and their allies will abandon their citizens, as Australia and its allies have abandoned Assange (Cameron, 2010, para 9). It also makes us aware of the “fundamental shift in the balance of power towards the citizens and away from the institutions that govern them” (Cameron, 2010, para 1).

Ayton-Shenker (1995, para 1) also puts forward about attempts to define a new world order, and a time of global transition. Again, the shift in the balance of power is raised, specifically with reference to the cessation of super-power rivalry (Ayton-Shenker, 1995, para 2). Demographic shifts and new political alliances (Ayton-Shenker 1995, para 3) also indicate that the balance of power is changing. However, with the changing in the balance of power, challenges to the Universal Human Rights are also raised (Ayton-Shenker, 2010, para 6).

One of the most controversial of the human rights issues in Australia is the “banning of the burqa” issue (Haussegger, 2010, para 3). Others also make us aware that the banning of the burqa is a controversial issue in other countries such as in Belgium, Italy, Netherlands and Canada (Haussegger, 2010, para 2). France (Ranciere, 2010, para 11), Switzerland (Eltahawy, Dec 2009, para 1) and USA (Eltahawy, Jun 2009, para 4) also have issues with the burqa, as is also reported by Haussegger (2010, para 2).

Again, the prospect of indoctrination, or an attack on personal freedoms (Haussegger, 2005, para 5) is raised. Ayton-Shenker (2010, para 28) states that every person has the right to cultural freedom, as long as it does not infringe on another human right. However, the trend of “cultural relativism” to violate or deny human rights is itself an abuse of the right to culture (Ayton-Shenker, 2005, para 29).Similar abuses based on “cold racism” are also raised by Ranciere (2010, para 4). In particular, laws brought in by France since 1993 are viewed as racist policies under a veil of anti-racism (Ranciere, 2010, para 3). These freedoms are paramount to indoctrination as cited by Chomsky.

An interesting paradox arises when this issue is raised: freedom of religion and women’s rights (Haussegger, 2005, para 5).Some claim the burqa is repressive and discriminatory against women, because they are forced to wear it by men, who view women as inferior (Haussegger, 2005, para 5). It is also put forward the the burqa is not part of culture or religion, but is designed by men to keep women subordinate (Haussegger, 2005, para 12).

The burqa is also seen as a stereotypical view of the situation regarding Muslim women (Eltahawy, Jun 2009, para 4). The burqa issue is also cited by Eltahawy as evading the real crusade by women against male dominated interpretations of religion (Eltahawy, Jun 2009, para 4). Chomsky (2002) addressed this phenomenon when he wrote of the media manufacturing content to influence how people perceive issues.

The Green Left (2010, para 2) state that banning the burqa is wrong, which again attempts to give the public a voice in the argument, which Chomsky (2002) said the public were generally unable to do. However, this statement seems in contrast the Universal Human Rights principle that cultural rights cannot be used as an excuse to deny or violate other human rights or infringe on freedoms (Ayton-Shenka, 2005, para 29).

In seeming contradiction to their own statement that banning the burqa is wrong (Green Left, 2010, para 2), the Green Left also write that forcing women to wear the burqa is wrong (Green Left, 2010, para 1). This seems to be a debate style of writing to allow both points of an argument to be set forward, so people can make their own choice, a principle of critical thinking put forward by Facione (2010, pp 19-20).

Such critical thinking is addressed by Guillot (2004) when he refers to concepts as being the most powerful element of critical thinking. By using the principle of concepts, it may be possible to minimise the effects of indoctrination by media (Chomsky, 2002), by being able to change concepts. Guillot (2004) puts forward the non-critical thinkers are unable to change their concepts.

As an extension of the burqa issue, Ranciere (2010, para 1) has an overall view of “state racism.” He particularly expounds on this with his criticism of states imposing laws based on contradictions of ideological and practical functions (Ranciere, 2010, para 7-8). On the specific issue of the banning of the burqa, Ranciere (2010, para 11) stated that a general law was passed supposedly to address everyone, but the reality was that it was aimed at a minority of Muslim women.

If this was in fact the case, there is support for the argument that it is a violation of human rights as cultural relativism (Ayton-Shenker, 2005, para 29). However, Ayton-Shenker (2005, para 28) also writes that the purpose of the burqa violates other human rights, so from that it could be concluded that banning the burqa is not a violation of Universal Human Rights. This is perhaps an excellent example of what Guillot (2002) was expounding when he spoke of concepts. The public must be able to draw its own inferences from these concepts, rather than conceding to the creation of necessary illusion cited by Chomsky (2002, p. 5).

The media are able to utilise their communication skills to change how the public thinks by imposing a new way of thinking by the “creation of necessary illusion” (Chomsky, 2002, p.5).

Reference List

2Critical4You, (2009, March 5). Outfoxed Part 1 . Retrieved from: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ok01hJHvobM

2Critical4You, (2009, March 5). Outfoxed Part 2 . Retrieved from: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RAGTvyn-rOo&feature=related

Air University (2011). Critical Thinking. Retreived from: http://www.au.af.mil/au/awc/awcgate/awc-thkg.htm

Ayton-Shenker, D. (1995). The challenge of human rights and cultural diversity. Retrieved from: http://www.un.org/rights/dpi1627e.htm

Barsamian, D. (2002). U.S. intervention from Afghanistan to Iraq: Noam Chomsky interviewed by David Barsamian. International Socialist Review. Retrieved from http://www.chomsky.info/interviews/200209–.htm

Cameron, Ross. (2011, January 13). Can’t hide love for WikiLeaks. National Times. Retrieved from: http://www.nationaltimes.com.au/opinion/politics/cant-hide-love-for-wikileaks-20110112-19o1w.html

Chomsky, N. (1992). Israel, the Holocaust, and Anti-Semitism. Excerpted from Chronicles of Dissent. Retrieved from: http://www.chomsky.info/books/dissent01.htm

Eltahawy, M. (2009, June 16). Headscarves and hymens. Huffington Post. Retrieved from: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/mona-eltahawy/headscarves-and-hymens_b_216236.html

Eltahawy, M. (2009, December 1). Europe’s call to intolerance. Washington Post. Retrieved from: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/11/30/AR2009113003729.html

Facione, P. A. 2010. Critical thinking: what it is and why it counts. Measured Reasons. California Academic Press

Guilot, W. M. 2004. Critical thinking for the military professional. Air and Space Power Journal. Retrieved at http://www.airpower.au.af.mil/airchronicles/cc/guillot.html

Green Left. (2010, September 25). Should the burqa be banned? Green Left Weekly. Retrieved from: http://www.greenleft.org.au/node/45501

Haussegger, V. (2010, May 21). The burqa is a war on women. Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved from: http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/society-and-culture/the-burqa-is-a-war-on-women-20100520-vnp3.html

Hitchens, C. (2010, December 11). Middleman peddles his ill-gotten goods. The Australian. Retrieved from: http://www.theaustralian.com.au/in-depth/wikileaks/christopher-hitchens-on-julian-assange/story-fn775xjq-1225969087171

Neversaidb4 (2008, June 24). Reel Bad Arabs: How Hollywood Vilifies a People (part 1) . Retrieved from: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k1-Bbz_TBMc

Ranciere, J. (2010). Racism: A Passion from Above, MRzine, 23 September. Retrieved from: http://mrzine.monthlyreview.org/2010/ranciere230910.html

Weir, A. (2004). Israel and Palestine: Choosing Sides. In P. Phillips, Censored 2005: The top 25 Censored Stories (pp. 1-13). U.S.A: Seven Stories Press.


One thought on “Critical Thinking: Media and Democracy

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

If you liked what you just read, click "Subscribe" to become a follower of the Craig Hill site. You will receive an email each time a new post is published.

Join 14,929 other followers

An archive of all my old posts

Follow me on Twitter

Most Recent Posts Post on My Blog About China: China News

Could China’s economy collapse?

Could China’s economy collapse?

For almost half a century, Chinese officials have overseen one of the greatest economic transformations in human history. The country has gone from collectivized farms and famine to world-leading tech companies and gleaming megacities connected by superfast trains. More than 800 million Chinese have been pulled out of poverty as the Communist Party and its leader […]

China’s economic crisis is much bigger than expected – its property market, the largest in the world, is collapsing

China’s economic crisis is much bigger than expected – its property market, the largest in the world, is collapsing

The situation in China is much worse than originally thought.  The largest property market in the world is set to collapse and the ramifications will impact the entire world.  We’ve been discussing China’s economic issues for years.  Recently this was even discussed with Steve Bannon on The War Room. We now have information that the […]

UN must condemn forced organ harvesting in China

UN must condemn forced organ harvesting in China

Doctors, lawyers, and politicians from three continents called on the international community to ensure an end to China’s practice of forced organ harvesting during the first half of the World Summit on Combating and Preventing Forced Organ Harvesting. Doctors Against Forced Organ Harvesting (DAFOH) further calls upon the participants of the United Nations General Assembly […]

China says its J-31 is superior to F-35, and will be new carrier-borne fighter jet

China says its J-31 is superior to F-35, and will be new carrier-borne fighter jet

Dwnews.com describes the J-31 in its report “曝歼31配新型导弹高清照 被指将终结美军空中优势[图]” as China’s new carrier-borne fighter jet for China’s Type 003 aircraft carrier. The speculation is based on the J-31’s Chief Designer Sun Cong’s recent comment on social media that China will make public its new carrier-borne fighter jet by year end. The report describes the J-31 as […]

The reason for the discussion on the Tobin tax in China

The reason for the discussion on the Tobin tax in China

Tax every major financial transaction for social equity by a fraction and allocate the funds to redistribution initiatives. The Tobin tax is the shattered dream of the anti-globalist left, even if its history is slightly more complex. Formulated in 1972 by James Tobin, the 1981 Nobel laureate in economics, it aimed to stabilize the financial […]

Is another Cultural Revolution underway in China?

Is another Cultural Revolution underway in China?

Chinese President Xi Jinping is cracking down on several sectors of Chinese society, including technology and entertainment. This has some Beijing watchers worried a new version of Chairman Mao Zedong’s Cultural Revolution is underway. Here’s everything you need to know. What was the Cultural Revolution? It was a brutal 10-year period between 1966-76 (with most […]

Cadence Column: Asia, October 11, 2021

Cadence Column: Asia, October 11, 2021

Biden is creating a special center within CIA for China. Xi Jinping is irate. Biden knows China almost as well as Trump. He met with Chinese officials as Vice President. While Trump played a “good cop” routine on China, Biden is in a better position to be less diplomatic. After all, hating on China does […]

The curious case of Pakistan, China, TTP and BRI

The curious case of Pakistan, China, TTP and BRI

On 1st October Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan broke all hell loose when on the Turkish government-run TV channel, TRT World, he disclosed that the Pakistani government is in secret talks with Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), facilitated by the Afghan Taliban. The Pakistanis were upset for many reasons. They were upset that they were kept in […]

China’s electronic warfare aircraft J-16D spotted near Taiwan; experts say India border could be next

China’s electronic warfare aircraft J-16D spotted near Taiwan; experts say India border could be next

China is rapidly acquiring new military technologies and weapons as it tries to dominate the Indo-Pacific region, especially the South China Sea which it considers as its backyard. The J-16D electronic warfare aircraft (EWA) is one such platform that stood out at the recently concluded Zhuhai airshow and according to reports, PLA has deployed the […]

Instead of confronting China’s rise, we must manage its decline

Instead of confronting China’s rise, we must manage its decline

Nations, like people, have reputations, and in both cases there can be gaps between the rep and the reality. China is known as the sage of nations, strategically patient, thinking in terms of centuries while the West flits about like a toddler in a toy store. Current events are forcing a reappraisal, however, as China […]

%d bloggers like this: