//
you're reading...
Australian Current Affairs

New Australian defence white paper fails to recognise China as any threat whatsoever


Australia Defence White PaperAsia is a potentially turbulent region, yet Australia has no sensible defence strategy.

For more than 40 years Australia has been able to assume that it is a secure country in a peaceful region. That has kept its defence needs low and defence budget modest.

Now Asia is changing fast, and the old assumptions no longer hold. The Defence white paper due out this week offers a chance to respond, but the government seems certain to miss it.

The government has acknowledged that the strategic landscape is shifting fast by deciding to deliver the white paper now, a year ahead of schedule. But the new document will not explain why things are changing or what it means for our defence, because that would mean talking about China, which the government does not want to do.

China is central to the future of Australian defence policy because it is challenging America for regional leadership. That is a huge change. The main reason Asia has been so peaceful for the past 40 years is America’s primacy has been uncontested. China’s growing challenge is overturning that, which shakes the foundations of Australia’s security. We cannot know how it will turn out.

The last Defence white paper in 2009 acknowledged this, but its muddled analysis suggested China posed a direct threat to Australia. That goes too far. China’s rise is transforming the strategic landscape on which our security depends, but it is not threatening Australia directly – at least not yet.

Now the new white paper seems headed too far the other way. The government seems convinced that China’s rise poses no serious strategic questions at all. It ignores the escalating rivalry between Washington and Beijing, and Beijing’s starker confrontations with Tokyo. It says that leaders in Washington, Beijing and Tokyo will not let things get out of hand because that would be in no one’s interest, as Prime Minister Julia Gillard said last week. That assumes that no one makes mistakes.

Of course the government is right to say that conflict is not inevitable. It is quite possible for the US, China and Japan to find a way to live in peace. But that will not be easy, and we’d be unwise to base our defence policy on the breezy assumption that all will work out well. The whole point of armed forces is to guard against the risk that things will go wrong.

One can see why the government wants to avoid acknowledging the growing risks. Playing down the strategic consequences of China’s rise will avoid ructions with Beijing that would dim the glow from Gillard’s recent visit. But more important, it will deflect pressure to overhaul Australia’s defence policy, rethink the current plans for new capabilities and revisit the size of the Defence budget, all of which the rise of China makes urgently necessary.

Australia’s defence policy today still dates back to the 1970s, when America emerged as Asia’s unchallenged strategic leader. Back then we abandoned forward defence in Asia because America no longer needed the kind of support we had given in the ’50s and ’60s in conflicts such as Korea, Malaya and Vietnam. In fact, Australia stopped thinking about Asia’s major powers as a factor in our defence planning at all.

Instead we focused on our own backyard, designing forces to stave off minor attacks from Indonesia and help stabilise our small island neighbours. That only started to change in John Howard’s 2000 Defence white paper, which recognised that China’s rise was already challenging the old assumptions, and Kevin Rudd’s 2009 white paper maintained that trend.

But now it seems we are heading back to the 1970s. The signs are that the new white paper will quietly return to a narrow focus on defending Australia from low-level attacks, presumably from Indonesia, and the kind of stabilisation operations we have been doing in East Timor and the Solomon Islands.

The advantage is that we can afford the forces to do these things with a defence budget under 2 per cent of GDP. But those forces will be little use if Gillard is wrong and we face a more turbulent and contested region. They would provide no options to seriously support America in a clash with China or to protect our own interests in a more contested Asia. So it would be a defence policy that assumed the next four decades will be just like the past four. It would be a defence policy that just hopes for the best.

It need not be that way. Designing an effective and affordable defence force that would give Australia real strategic weight in the Asian Century is a formidably difficult undertaking, but there are real options we could explore. Inevitably such a force would be different from the one we now have, and it would cost more. We would have to spend the kind of money we did in the ’50s and ’60s, when we last faced a turbulent region.

The government is not willing to address these issues. Instead it remains committed to the existing plans to build an increasingly irrelevant defence force. And those plans are becoming increasingly unrealistic. Defence Minister Stephen Smith has promised nothing will be cut from the current defence program, but after the past few years’ budget cuts this would require bigger funding increases than seems at all likely in today’s fiscal climate, and there is a fair chance he will make things worse by ordering another Air Warfare Destroyer to keep the shipyards busy.

The only good news is that many of those involved in producing the new white paper understand that it is just a stop-gap that will leave all the big questions unanswered. A new Abbott government would probably want to produce its own white paper. The trouble is that Abbott shows no more sign of taking defence policy seriously than Gillard does. Meanwhile strategic rivalry in Asia just keeps rising.

Hugh White is professor of strategic studies at the Strategic and Defence Studies Centre, ANU
 
Source: The Age – Real defence policy needed in Asian Century
 

About Craig Hill

Teacher and Writer. Writing has been cited in New York Times, BBC, Fox News, Aljazeera, Philippines Star, South China Morning Post, National Interest, news.com.au, Wikipedia and others.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

If you liked what you just read, click "Subscribe" to become a follower of the Craig Hill site. You will receive an email each time a new post is published.

Join 17,663 other followers

An archive of all my old posts

Follow me on Twitter

Most Recent Posts Post on My Blog About China: China News

Chinese drones now almost a daily appearance over Taiwan

Chinese drones now almost a daily appearance over Taiwan

The Chinese military has intensified its drone incursions into the skies above Taiwan with almost daily flights of combat and reconnaissance unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs). Taiwan’s Defense Ministry said a People’s Liberation Army (PLA) TB-001 drone was spotted crossing the median line of the Taiwan Strait, the de facto boundary between the island and China’s […]

India says disengagement along disputed area with China to be completed by September 12

India says disengagement along disputed area with China to be completed by September 12

India’s foreign ministry said on Friday that disengagement along a disputed border area with China will be completed by Sept. 12. Both countries began disengaging from the Gogra-Hot Springs border area in the western Himalayas on Thursday, over two years after clashes at the frontier strained diplomatic ties. The disengagement comes ahead of a meeting […]

How to make EVs without China’s supply chain

How to make EVs without China’s supply chain

Two electrifying moves in recent weeks have the potential to ignite electric vehicle demand in the United States. First, Congress passed the Inflation Reduction Act, expanding federal tax rebates for EV purchases. Then California approved rules to ban the sale of new gasoline-powered cars by 2035. The Inflation Reduction Act extends the Obama-era EV tax […]

Anti-India forces: Techniques and agendas exposed

Anti-India forces: Techniques and agendas exposed

In the post-cold war era, India has moved from a policy of non-alignment to a policy of multi-alignment. This means that India has friendly relations with almost all-powerful and developing nations. Today India is carving out a unique path for itself. Such an approach provides prominence and exposes India to the harmful behind-curtain activities by […]

Taiwan’s Kinmen serves as a reminder of China’s aggression

Taiwan’s Kinmen serves as a reminder of China’s aggression

Taiwan’s frontline island of Kinmen was once again in the headlines when President Tsai Ing-wen paid tribute this week to the soldiers and civilians who “operated in solidarity and safeguarded Taiwan” 64 years ago. On Aug. 23, 1958 mainland Chinese troops attacked Kinmen in a key battle that marked the beginning of the Second Taiwan […]

Terrorism: The glue that holds China and Pakistan together 

Terrorism: The glue that holds China and Pakistan together 

The father of communism, Karl Marx, once famously said — “We have no compassion, and we ask no compassion from you. When our turn comes, we shall not make excuses for the terror”. This statement summarises how terrorism and communism go hand in hand. Maoist China alone destroyed between 44.5 to 72 million lives. During […]

‘New normal’ across the Taiwan Strait as China threat looms ever closer

‘New normal’ across the Taiwan Strait as China threat looms ever closer

China is attempting to establish a “new normal” across the Taiwan Strait, eroding self-ruled Taiwan’s territorial control and increasing the threat of a strike with each military sortie, officials and analysts say. Beijing has ramped up military maneuvers in the 110-mile (180-kilometer) wide stretch of water that separates Taiwan from mainland China — and the […]

When Beijing was burning, Xi was playing personal games 

When Beijing was burning, Xi was playing personal games 

A great fire destroyed Rome for six days in the summer of AD 64. Famous Roman historian of that time, Tacitus, recorded that 70 percent of the city was destroyed and half of the city’s residents were displaced. Roman ruler Nero was accused of being indifferent, ineffective, and careless. The end result of this neglect […]

China would re-educate Taiwan in event of reunification

China would re-educate Taiwan in event of reunification

Once China achieves its professed goal of establishing control over Taiwan, a process of “re-education” of the island’s population would follow, according to China’s Ambassador to France Lu Shaye. The ambassador was speaking on French television channel BFM TV on Wednesday night, when he said a majority of the Taiwanese population actually wanted to be […]

Sri Lanka’s economic crisis is a political sabotage

Sri Lanka’s economic crisis is a political sabotage

Sri Lanka’s present state confirms the famous statement: “Insanity is doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting different results.” Sri Lankans have been repeating the mistakes of choosing the politicians Rajapaksas again and again. It is confirmed that there were unaccounted payments that the Chinese were liberal with during project negotiations with the island nation. They were paid […]

%d bloggers like this: