you're reading...
Australian Law and Politics

Court Of Appeal Clarifies Scope Of Appeals Against Acquittal

The New South Wales Occupational Health & Safety Act (Act) permits the prosecutor to appeal to a Full Bench of the Industrial Court of New South Wales, against a verdict of acquittal. This is an exception to the normal principles of criminal law. Recently the New South Wales Court of Appeal was called upon to consider the scope of the orders which the Full Bench can make in determining such an appeal.

The case (Bros Bins Systems Pty Limited v Industrial Court of New South Wales [2008] NSWCA 292) is another example of the type of long running litigation to which, it appears, the Act is prone. The difficulty arises because of the need to reconcile two competing principles of interpretation – on the one hand, the need to give a broad or generous construction to legislation that is designed to secure a public benefit and, on the other hand, the need to follow an approach of strict construction because the Act is also penal in nature.

Bros Bins operated a business involving the removal of industrial rubbish. The company owned a number of trucks that were specially fitted with a hydraulic bin mechanism. One of the trucks required repair and for that purpose was taken to Tibby Rose Auto, an auto repair business. An employee of Bros Bins (Mr Wood) drove the truck to the premises of Tibby Rose Auto and remained there whilst the vehicle was worked on by an employee of Tibby Rose Auto.

During the course of the repairs, the bin mechanism was raised. Some time later it fell, killing an employee of Tibby Rose Auto. It was accepted that another employee of Tibby Rose Auto had touched a control lever that caused the mechanism to descend.

Bros Bins was charged under what is now section 10(2) of the Act, which requires that a person who has control of plant (to any extent) that is used by people at work must ensure that the plant is safe and without risks to health.

At first instance, the trial judge (Marks J) acquitted Bros Bins on the basis that the truck was not “plant” for the purposes of the Act. Whilst the truck was at the premises of Tibby Rose Auto, it represented the product of work processes carried out by Tibby Rose Auto and it was not a fixture, implement or apparatus used in the carrying on of the work.

The prosecutor brought an appeal to a Full Bench of the Industrial Court. The prosecutor argued that the word “plant” in the Act should not be given a narrow meaning, and the mere fact the truck was being repaired did not mean that it was not plant.

Bros Bins argued that if such a view was to be accepted it would be impossible for a company to have an item of machinery or equipment repaired by a third party without breaching the Act. In effect the company could only discharge its obligation if it had the plant fixed before it was given to the repairer. Such an absurd result could not have been intended by Parliament. It might be thought that, at a common sense level, this argument has much to commend it.

The Full Bench did not agree and concluded that the vehicle constituted “plant” under the Act. The Full Bench set aside the acquittal and directed that the matter be returned to Marks J for rehearing.

At the rehearing, the company was found guilty. A subsequent appeal to the Full Bench was unsuccessful.

The company then applied for a review of the decision by the New South Wales Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal possesses a supervisory jurisdiction under which it may quash a decision of the Full Bench if that decision is affected by jurisdictional error.

Bros Bins argued that jurisdictional error occurred in two ways, namely:

  1. the Full Bench’s conclusion that the truck constituted plant under the Act; and
  2. the right of appeal against acquittal does not permit the Full Bench to remit the matter for re-trial to a single judge of the Court.

On the first ground, the Court of Appeal concluded that even if the Full Bench had been in error, the mistake was not jurisdictional in nature and so the Court of Appeal had no capacity to intervene.

However, Bros Bins was successful on the second ground. The Court of Appeal held that the right against double jeopardy is such a powerfully entrenched right within our law, that it can only be abrogated by the express will of Parliament. Parliament had expressed its will to permit an appeal against acquittal (and so to abrogate double jeopardy), but if it had been Parliament’s intention that the consequence of a successful appeal could be a rehearing, then this would have been made clear within the legislation. It was not.

The Court of Appeal ordered that the re-trial conducted before Marks J was beyond jurisdiction and the results of it were void. The matter was sent back to be fully determined by the Full Bench.

The course of this litigation is a further indication that the jurisprudence relating to the operation of key provisions of the Act may have become unbalanced and that the penal aspect of the legislation is not sufficiently taken into account. It is difficult, again at a common sense level, to accept that a person who seeks to get a vehicle repaired should be penalised because of an accident that the repairer has caused.

It is noteworthy that the recommendations of the advisory panel (referred to in the Report on National Harmonisation of OHS Laws) have made it clear that the model national OHS legislation should not allow appeals from acquittal. The recommendations of the panel also state that a right of appeal against conviction and/or sentence should exist to the relevant State Supreme Court and, thereafter, to the High Court. This measure would serve to prevent any tendency toward unrealistically absolute interpretations of the Act.

Article by Deacons Solicitors, Australia

About Craig Hill

Teacher and Writer. Writing has been cited in New York Times, BBC, Fox News, Aljazeera, Philippines Star, South China Morning Post, National Interest, news.com.au, Wikipedia and others.


No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

If you liked what you just read, click "Subscribe" to become a follower of the Craig Hill site. You will receive an email each time a new post is published.

Join 15,052 other followers

An archive of all my old posts

Follow me on Twitter

Most Recent Posts Post on My Blog About China: China News

Chinese geo-strategic expansion in the Levant: A case study of Lebanon

Chinese geo-strategic expansion in the Levant: A case study of Lebanon

As soon as the People’s Republic of China was established in 1949, China and the Middle East faced a series of challenges. In recent years, China’s influence in the region has expanded due to its economic interests in energy, trade, infrastructure construction, and diplomatic contacts with the region’s countries. This is linked to President Xi […]

The Chinese Communist Party still thinks it owns the future

The Chinese Communist Party still thinks it owns the future

A rising chorus of analysts now describe China as a “peaking power”—one that might take greater risks to revise the international order before its strategic window of opportunity closes. They cite the country’s aging population , slowing economy , and hostile external environment  as evidence that time is no longer on China’s side. The “fear of decline,” they […]

Chinese maritime militia threatens order in South China Sea

Chinese maritime militia threatens order in South China Sea

Hundreds of Chinese maritime militia vessels are operating in contested areas of the South China Sea on a consistent basis, according to a new U.S. think tank report that says this poses a significant challenge to “maritime order rooted in international law.” The Washington, D.C.,-based Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), says that for […]

Cadence Column: Asia, November 22, 2021

Cadence Column: Asia, November 22, 2021

The world is not responding well to the so-called “plandemic”. The important thing is not whether the global disease, as said by Judy Mikovits to have been developed under the supervision of Fauci, was actually intended to do all this. The public thinks it was because governments haven’t work carefully to earn public trust. Even […]

Tackling Chinese technological advantage 

Tackling Chinese technological advantage 

“China has won the artificial intelligence battle with the United States and is heading towards global dominance because of its technological advances”. When the Pentagon’s former software chief Nick Chaillan made this claim, it felt as if the whole world had come crashing down. The whole episode gave rise to the debate about who’s ahead […]

Biden and Xi move back from the brink

Biden and Xi move back from the brink

The three-and-half-hour virtual summit meeting between President Joe Biden and Chinese President Xi Jinping did not, and could not, solve the fundamental problems that have driven the two great powers toward confrontation. But both men clearly wanted to challenge the misperception that they are on the brink of conflict, and to prevent an unintended escalation […]

Celebrities who disappeared in China after speaking out about the Communist Party or powerful people

Celebrities who disappeared in China after speaking out about the Communist Party  or powerful people

Peng Shuai has not been heard from since she accused a top Chinese official of sexual assault. The 35-year-old tennis player is one of China’s biggest sports stars. In a post on November 2 on Weibo, Peng alleged the former vice-premier Zhang Gaoli coerced her into sex and that they had an affair. Afterward, the post was taken […]

China’s ‘leftover women’ using their financial power to fight stigma

China’s ‘leftover women’ using their financial power to fight stigma

In China, if you are female, educated and unmarried by the age of 27, people might use a particular term – “sheng-nu” – to describe your social status. It translates simply as “leftover woman.” The label was deliberately invented to curb the rising number of single women in a traditional society that sometimes views not […]

Health workers in China are killing pets while their owners are in quarantine

Health workers in China are killing pets while their owners are in quarantine

Local health workers in some Chinese cities are breaking into people’s homes and killing their pets while the owners are in quarantine, prompting outrage online. In one case, a dog owner named Ms Fu witnessed through her home security camera as people clothed in hazmat suits entered her home and beat her pet corgi to […]

Xi Jinping’s Terrifying New China

Xi Jinping’s Terrifying New China

China’s social media was briefly aflutter this fall about an impressive feat in the popular online fantasy game Honor of Kings. A player had completed a “pentakill,” or five kills in a row, but something just smelled wrong: The user in question was 60 years old, according to the verified account information—hardly the type to […]

%d bloggers like this: