you're reading...
Australian Current Affairs

Australia’s asylum policy fails to have an impact

Almost 20,000 asylum seekers have arrived since the government's new policy was embraced on August 13, and not one has been processed

Almost 20,000 asylum seekers have arrived since the government’s new policy was embraced on August 13, and not one has been processed

It was the foundation stone of Julia Gillard‘s plan to stop, or at least substantially slow, the flow of boats arriving uninvited on our shores, and it had a certain simplicity and logic on its side.

If asylum seekers could extract ”no advantage” by paying people smugglers and risking their lives on leaky boats, compared with staying and having their refugee claims processed in countries such as Malaysia and Indonesia, it stood to reason they would stop coming.

But more than nine months after the Prime Minister embraced the principle, two things are apparent: no clear definition of ”no advantage” has emerged and the policy has failed to have an impact. If anything, it has been a boon for the smugglers.

The scorecard of failure emerged this week as public servants were grilled in Senate estimates committee hearings, and seemed better-equipped at defining what the principle was not, rather than what is was.


Almost 20,000 asylum seekers have arrived since the policy was embraced on August 13, and not one has been processed. Moreover, about 7250 have been released into the community on bridging visas without the right to work, and with minimal support.

While the Coalition used most of its questions in the House this week to suggest that inadequate security checks on those released posed a threat to the community, a very different reality was confronting those in the voluntary sector and those who had been released.

Among them is a Hazara couple who were given bridging visas after spending four months in detention on Christmas Island and in Western Australia. After paying the rent and weekly instalments on their bond, they have just $30 a week each to cover all other expenses.

Sister Brigid Arthur, who has been finding donated furniture and bedding for the couple, says the woman is wary of turning on the small heater or the stove in the flat for fear that they will not be able to pay the power bill. ”Their focus is on survival day to day,” Sister Brigid says.

In the estimates committee hearings, Department of Immigration secretary Martin Bowles insisted that the approach – including sending about 800 asylum seekers to languish in centres in Nauru and Papua New Guinea’s Manus Island – was not about punishing them, nor deterring others.

He also asserted there had not been a freeze on processing the claims of the post-August 13 arrivals, despite the lack of action, and maintained that the ”no advantage” principle applied to the issuing of visas, not the processing of claims – meaning those eventually found to be refugees could wait years before receiving visas.

Many in the refugee sector were unconvinced – including David Manne, the lawyer who has led a series of successful High Court challenges in this area. ”What is quite clear to us is that there is a very serious lack of understanding, and a collective confusion at the most fundamental level, by everyone involved in the sector, including government about what the principle is and how it is being applied,” he says.

Australian Human Rights Commissioner Gillian Triggs told a parliamentary hearing the government’s no-advantage policies and offshore processing had no legal context internationally. ”We urge the government to embark on assessing the validity or otherwise of the claims to refugee status,” she said.

It is now almost a year since Gillard appointed a panel led by former defence chief Angus Houston to do what the politicians palpably failed to do and come up with a policy that might avoid the growing number of tragedies at sea. The panel reported back in August and made 22 policy recommendations, which it said when taken as a package would reduce the number of arrivals.

”We recommend a policy approach that is hard-headed but not hard-hearted, that is realistic not idealistic, that is driven by a sense of humanity as well as fairness,” the panel said.

The government accepted, in principle, all of the recommendations and so far has focused on reintroducing offshore processing, embracing the ”no advantage” principle under which asylum claims will be processed ”no faster than if they’d used regular options”, and increasing Australia’s overall humanitarian intake.

Frustration at the absence of a clear definition of ”no advantage” prompted Victorian Labor MP Laura Smyth to move a resolution in caucus this week seeking one. This led to an undertaking from Immigration Minister Brendan O’Connor to ”flesh out” a definition in the coming weeks.

In August, Gillard offered this one: ”Not only would you process asylum seekers on Nauru and PNG, but you would not give them a protection visa which would enable them to come to Australia until the passage of the same amount of time as if they had waited at a refugee resettlement place earlier in the pipeline.”

But the policy goals quickly gave way to reality. Just three months later, then minister Chris Bowen said that, given the sheer numbers arriving, it was not possible to send everyone to Nauru or Manus Island. He announced that people who arrived after August 13 would be released into the community on a new form of bridging visa that forbade them from working and entitled them to a department-funded stipend of just $217 a week (the equivalent of 89 per cent of the dole).

This week, Bowles told the parliamentary hearing that releasing asylum seekers into the community cost just 20 per cent of the cost of keeping people in detention. The changes would save the department millions.

But church groups and non-government organisations say they are being forced to care for people being given up by the government.

Kon Karapanagiotidis, founder of the Asylum Seeker Resource Centre, says his organisation’s emergency housing budget has run out two months before the end of the financial year. The situation, he says, is the worst he has seen in 12 years of running the centre.

”Our people are sitting here and going, ‘what do I do today? Do I eat? Do I feed my child today? Do I fare-evade? Do I buy a blanket, do I turn on the heater?

”And when we see people actually going hungry, living in empty shit-houses that are derelict or filthy or dangerous and are filled with nothing – it’s killing us.”

The opposition’s focus this week was on linking asylum seekers on bridging visas with crime rates, even before it emerged that a convicted Egyptian terrorist who arrived by boat was mistakenly cleared by the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation for release into community detention.

There have been 17 cases of ”possible criminal conduct” involving asylum seekers on bridging visas, the estimates hearing was told, including eight who had been charged, and two who had been convicted. The number of people involved in possible criminal conduct, Bowles said, ”is still quite low in terms of the broader community”.

Refugee Council of Australia chief executive Paul Power says it is time for the government to change its approach. ”It’s been a monumental failure in terms of being a circuit-breaker,” he says.

”We’ve had volumes of arrivals bigger than anything we’ve had before and it desperately needs to be reassessed. You have to ask yourself, ‘what is this policy achieving?’ It’s not achieving any of the government’s political objectives; it’s not making any practical difference to what the government perceives to be the problem and it is crushing people in the process.

”Why is the government not actually questioning the fact that the current policy parameters are clearly not working from anyone’s perspective?”

While Gillard maintains that the government has embraced all the recommendations of the expert panel – and blames the record number of arrivals on the opposition’s refusal to do the same – it’s clear what has unfolded is at odds with what the panel sought.

Asked if the ”no advantage” principle has been articulated and applied in the way the panel anticipated, panel member Paris Aristotle replies flatly: ”No”.

”It’s not about processing. It’s not even about entitlements, including work rights. The whole thing with the no-advantage principle is create a regional system, place people back into that system if they come by smugglers, and process them there,” he says. ”Now, you don’t give them an advantage over other people being processed in the regional system you create, but you also don’t disadvantage them.”

Clearly, Aristotle is frustrated that more has not been done to create a regional system – either by allocating funds to build capacity in last month’s budget or in direct leader-to-leader dialogue with Indonesia and Malaysia.

He is also dismayed that virtually none of the safeguards recommended for the processing centre on Manus Island has been implemented – and that children are among those subjected to arbitrary detention, inadequate accommodation and no processing.

A bigger concern is that the longer it takes to put an effective regional system in place, the bigger the pipeline becomes. ”For every month we hold off doing something, you would add multiple months on the other end before you bring it under some sort of better managed system,” he says. ”That will be the same, regardless of who is in government after September 14.”

Source: Sydney Morning Herald – No-advantage policy springs a few leaks

About Craig Hill

Teacher and Writer. Writing has been cited in New York Times, BBC, Fox News, Aljazeera, Philippines Star, South China Morning Post, National Interest, news.com.au, Wikipedia and others.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

If you liked what you just read, click "Subscribe" to become a follower of the Craig Hill site. You will receive an email each time a new post is published.

Join 17,663 other followers

An archive of all my old posts

Follow me on Twitter

Most Recent Posts Post on My Blog About China: China News

China flexes new nuclear sub ahead of Party Congress

China flexes new nuclear sub ahead of Party Congress

For the first time, China has released video footage of its latest Type 094A nuclear-powered ballistic missile sub (SSBN) and Type 093 nuclear attack sub (SSN), a potent show of naval might ahead of China’s 20th Communist Party Congress in October. Chinese state media featured the subs in a training video for Liaoning, China’s first […]

Coronation Of Emperor Xi and the world thereafter

Coronation Of Emperor Xi and the world thereafter

A few days ago, Chinese President Xi Jinping‘s arrest news took social media by storm. The atmosphere was jubilant as if the whole world looked forward to Xi’s exit. The rumor turned out to be fake news; Xi’s third term looks secured. Xi Jinping is all set to snatch the historic third term in the […]

China is coming for your land

China is coming for your land

Drought has plunged water levels to the lowest in China in decades. The temperatures have also soared to record levels, and hydropower plants failed to meet the sharp rise in power demand. However, this is just a glimpse of the worst things to come. Floods, droughts, and record-breaking temperatures would have a catastrophic effect on […]

Chinese drones now almost a daily appearance over Taiwan

Chinese drones now almost a daily appearance over Taiwan

The Chinese military has intensified its drone incursions into the skies above Taiwan with almost daily flights of combat and reconnaissance unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs). Taiwan’s Defense Ministry said a People’s Liberation Army (PLA) TB-001 drone was spotted crossing the median line of the Taiwan Strait, the de facto boundary between the island and China’s […]

India says disengagement along disputed area with China to be completed by September 12

India says disengagement along disputed area with China to be completed by September 12

India’s foreign ministry said on Friday that disengagement along a disputed border area with China will be completed by Sept. 12. Both countries began disengaging from the Gogra-Hot Springs border area in the western Himalayas on Thursday, over two years after clashes at the frontier strained diplomatic ties. The disengagement comes ahead of a meeting […]

How to make EVs without China’s supply chain

How to make EVs without China’s supply chain

Two electrifying moves in recent weeks have the potential to ignite electric vehicle demand in the United States. First, Congress passed the Inflation Reduction Act, expanding federal tax rebates for EV purchases. Then California approved rules to ban the sale of new gasoline-powered cars by 2035. The Inflation Reduction Act extends the Obama-era EV tax […]

Anti-India forces: Techniques and agendas exposed

Anti-India forces: Techniques and agendas exposed

In the post-cold war era, India has moved from a policy of non-alignment to a policy of multi-alignment. This means that India has friendly relations with almost all-powerful and developing nations. Today India is carving out a unique path for itself. Such an approach provides prominence and exposes India to the harmful behind-curtain activities by […]

Taiwan’s Kinmen serves as a reminder of China’s aggression

Taiwan’s Kinmen serves as a reminder of China’s aggression

Taiwan’s frontline island of Kinmen was once again in the headlines when President Tsai Ing-wen paid tribute this week to the soldiers and civilians who “operated in solidarity and safeguarded Taiwan” 64 years ago. On Aug. 23, 1958 mainland Chinese troops attacked Kinmen in a key battle that marked the beginning of the Second Taiwan […]

Terrorism: The glue that holds China and Pakistan together 

Terrorism: The glue that holds China and Pakistan together 

The father of communism, Karl Marx, once famously said — “We have no compassion, and we ask no compassion from you. When our turn comes, we shall not make excuses for the terror”. This statement summarises how terrorism and communism go hand in hand. Maoist China alone destroyed between 44.5 to 72 million lives. During […]

‘New normal’ across the Taiwan Strait as China threat looms ever closer

‘New normal’ across the Taiwan Strait as China threat looms ever closer

China is attempting to establish a “new normal” across the Taiwan Strait, eroding self-ruled Taiwan’s territorial control and increasing the threat of a strike with each military sortie, officials and analysts say. Beijing has ramped up military maneuvers in the 110-mile (180-kilometer) wide stretch of water that separates Taiwan from mainland China — and the […]

%d bloggers like this: