//
you're reading...
Australian History

On This Day In Australia: In 1984, the racehorse Fine Cotton was the centre of a substitution scam in Queensland


Bold Personality, substituted as Fine Cotton, immediately after the race

On 14 August 1984, the racehorse Fine Cotton was the centre of a substitution scam at Eagle Farm Racecourse, Brisbane, Queensland. A horse called Bold Personality had run the race disguised to resemble Fine Cotton, to deceive bookmakers for millions.

Wagers on sporting events have always attracted undesirables looking for a way to cheat and win.

Doubtless some have been successful and undetected. Some were exposed and the perpetrators caught and subjected to the consequences.

Others have left one to scratch his head and wonder, “What were they thinking?”

Some schemes have included knowing participation of one or more of the competitors, willing or otherwise, such as a favoured fighter taking a fall in a certain round to an inferior opponent, but others, particularly those involving punting, require no knowledge, compulsion or consent on the part of the horse.

Yes, the jockey can be instructed to rein in a favourite to let a horse with longer odds prevail, but it could be safely said that the horse has no awareness of their participation in the scam.

Sometimes the cheater’s plan is so comical as to not only fall into the “What were they thinking?” category, but also include, “Who was daft enough to be sucked in?”

Such a case in punting was known as The Fine Cotton Affair.

Fine Cotton was foaled in 1976. His lineage was predominantly Australian, and included blood from Ajax, but he did have some British and Irish blood. His sire Aureo did have French blood via Wilkes, and while it may be politically incorrect to say, that may have had some influence in Fine Cotton’s form resulting in his opening as 33-1 odds for the Commerce Novice Handicap at Eagle Farm Racecourse on August 18th, 1984.

Seeking the opportunity to capitalize on those substantial odds, trainer Hayden Haitana and Agent John Gillespie hatched a scheme to ring-in Fine Cotton with another gelding, Bold Personality, a horse of decidedly superior capability.

Buying Bold Personality was not difficult, and credit should be given to Haitana and Gillespie for showing the prudence to at least use another gelding as opposed to a stallion or filly, and perhaps disregard that they failed initially to consider that Fine Cotton was brown with white markings on his hind legs while Bold Personality was a bay with no white whatsoever.

They subsequently dyed Bold Personality to more closely impersonate Fine Cotton, and upon realizing the absence of the white legs, conceived the foolhardy strategy of using white paint to apply the markings, and to further conceal the deception with white bandages when the white paint proved inadequate to the task.

While not the origin of the expression, “Horse of a different colour,” this was nonetheless perhaps the boldest attempt ever at making the Bard’s line fit the occasion.

Greed played a role in unraveling the plot. Placing substantial bets via confederates at numerous venues, Haitana and Gillespie succeeded in gaining the notice of bookmakers who questioned the plummet in odds on Fine Cotton from 33-1 to 7/2. This phenomenal drop somehow managed to elude the attention of VRC and AJC stewards.

Not privy to the ring-in, Gus Philpot, an apprentice jockey, supposedly made the comment that Fine Cotton was unusually docile while being loaded. This is noteworthy in that Fine Cotton had a reputation for reluctance and would have preferred remaining in his stall munching feed to running.

One would think any jockey, apprentice or otherwise, would have the wherewithal to immediately be aware that his mount had been switched, even if it had been replaced by an otherwise identical double.

The event concluded with Bold Personality, in his guise as Fine Cotton, posting a half head victory.

The substantial drop in odds did finally attract the notice of stewards, and the running paint on Bold Personality’s leg was deemed at least slightly suspicious.

Fine Cotton trainer Haitana was called to a steward initiated investigation, but was learned to have somewhat hastily departed the premises.

Disqualification resulted; the win was awarded to Harbour Gold, and all punters who had staked Fine Cotton aka. Bold Personality were not paid.

No less a figure than Bill Waterhouse and his son Robbie were implicated, an allegation they vehemently denied. They were subjected to a ban that was finally lifted in 1998, perhaps in the absence of incontrovertible evidence.

Gillespie and Haitana went to jail for there part in the Fine Cotton affair, and other participants received lifetime bans.

Undeterred by his sanction, Gillespie went on to further infamy including a multi-million dollar horse race in 2008, fraud, and other questionable scams.

His record includes over 300 convictions for numerous and varied offences. He later claimed that he had gotten away with almost $2 million from The Fine Cotton Affair, a widely disputed claim, which if true, would make the 5 months he served of his four year prison sentence fairly lucrative.

It’s probable the entire truth of the affair will never be completely divulged, but the Fine Cotton Affair will forever be inextricably part of Australian horse racing history, and will give additional meaning to the term, “painted pony.”

Source: Pro Group Racing

About Craig Hill

Teacher and Writer. Writing has been cited in New York Times, BBC, Fox News, Aljazeera, Philippines Star, South China Morning Post, National Interest, news.com.au, Wikipedia and others.

Discussion

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

If you liked what you just read, click "Subscribe" to become a follower of the Craig Hill site. You will receive an email each time a new post is published.

Join 14,947 other followers

An archive of all my old posts

Follow me on Twitter

Most Recent Posts Post on My Blog About China: China News

The vanishing allure of doing business in China

The vanishing allure of doing business in China

It is nothing new for foreign firms to endure shakedowns by the Chinese Communist Party. As far back as revolutionary times, Chairman Mao’s victorious troops did not directly confiscate foreign-owned assets as their Bolshevik forerunners had done in Russia. Instead, they wore them down with higher taxes and fines so big that eventually companies gave […]

Wikipedia blames pro-China infiltration for bans

Wikipedia blames pro-China infiltration for bans

Wikipedia has suffered an “infiltration” that sought to advance the aims of China, the US non-profit organisation that owns the volunteer-edited encyclopaedia has said. The Wikimedia Foundation told BBC News the infiltration had threatened the “very foundations of Wikipedia”. The foundation banned seven editors linked to a mainland China group. Wikimedians of Mainland China accused […]

Diaries of former Mao aide spark custody battle over unofficial history of China

Diaries of former Mao aide spark custody battle over unofficial history of China

Today, “Li materials” are the subject of a legal battle between Stanford University and Mr. Li’s widow in Beijing. This is a battle for custody of an unofficial history of China. In millions of handwritten Chinese characters, Mr. Li documents his early days in the party, the revolution that brought him to power and his […]

World’s dirtiest cities list raises issue: Why don’t politicians call out China?

World’s dirtiest cities list raises issue: Why don’t politicians call out China?

Ponder this: A new tally of global cities’ emissions finds that the top 25 are responsible for 52% of the planet’s urban greenhouse gas emissions. Twenty-three of those are in China. New York City is the first American city to appear, at No. 26. Out of the top 75, just four other American cities are listed […]

Cadence Column: Asia, September 13, 2021

Cadence Column: Asia, September 13, 2021

The easiest solution to China’s escalating situation in the South Sea is to enforce China’s own formal statements at face value. China says they respect other countries and do not want to militarize the South Sea. Leave it at that. Any disrespect toward other countries is not at the behest of Xijinping. Any militarization of […]

Why is Iran so keen on joining the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation?

Why is Iran so keen on joining the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation?

What Happened: Iran became an observer in the Shanghai Cooperation Organization – originally comprised of China, Russia, and 4 Central Asian republics – back in 2005. In the 16 years since, Tehran has consistently pushed for an upgrade to full membership, particularly after the SCO underwent its first expansion, adding India and Pakistan, in 2017. […]

How China hijacked the war on terror to commit genocide in Xinjiang

How China hijacked the war on terror to commit genocide in Xinjiang

Two decades after the 9/11 attacks spawned the U.S. government’s self-declared “Global War on Terrorism,” the nation that responded to it with the most aggressive regulatory, policing and social policies is thousands of miles from Ground Zero. China’s ruling Chinese Communist Party exploited the international revulsion toward terrorism sparked by the 9/11 attacks to reframe […]

China extends a fast helping hand to the Taliban

China extends a fast helping hand to the Taliban

China has reassured the Taliban that it is ready to begin development activities in Afghanistan via its ambitious multi-trillion-dollar Belt and Road initiative (BRI), as the war-torn country drifts toward an economic meltdown. In what some see as Beijing’s tacit approval of the Afghan militant group’s interim government, China announced on Wednesday (September 8) US$31 […]

China’s population enters ‘deep aging’ in many major cities

China’s population enters ‘deep aging’ in many major cities

China is facing a population crisis of increasing urgency, with 149 cities shown in recent census figures to have 14 percent of their residents over the age of 65. A recent analysis by the state-run China Business News (CBN) found that 149 cities in China have now entered “deep aging,” the middle state on a […]

China weighing occupation of former U.S. air base at Bagram in Afghanistan

China weighing occupation of former U.S. air base at Bagram in Afghanistan

China is considering deploying military personnel and economic development officials to Bagram airfield, perhaps the single-most prominent symbol of the 20-year U.S. military presence in Afghanistan.  The Chinese military is currently conducting a feasibility study about the effect of sending workers, soldiers and other staff related to its foreign economic investment program known as the […]

%d bloggers like this: