//
you're reading...
Australian Current Affairs

Australia’s media regulation plan “unconstitutional”


Former Australian High Court judge Ian Callinan has produced a damning legal opinion that says aspects of the media regulation plan drawn up by former communications minister Stephen Conroy “are very arguably unlikely to be valid under the Constitution”.

The opinion, written jointly with Sydney barrister Caspar Conde, says the broad powers proposed for a statutory regulator of all news media would be likely to have generated a successful constitutional challenge.

The proposed regulator, known as the public interest media advocate, would have been a part-time statutory officer, informed and advised by government officials, and armed with wide discretion to replace the Australian Press Council and other “self-regulatory” bodies if they failed to control the press in a way that satisfied the PIMA.

Mr Callinan and Mr Conde said the PIMA’s powers would have been subjective and imprecise.

“The legislation would allow, indeed require, PIMA through its control and review of news media self-regulation bodies to impose requirements which affect, and we would suggest may burden, freedom of communication by news media organisations that are members of that body.”

The bills to establish the scheme could be compared with “blanket bans” on political communication that had been held by the High Court to be unconstitutional in earlier cases, the opinion says.

“It would be unfortunate if the bills in their current imprecise and potentially far-reaching present form were to be enacted.”

Their opinion says the government may well have underestimated dramatically the costs associated with the scheme as the PIMA would have required substantial funds to discharge its responsibilities.

Mr Callinan and Mr Conde were commissioned to prepare the opinion by the Institute of Public Affairs, which called yesterday for the federal government to provide a clear guarantee that it would not seek to reintroduce an amended version of the Conroy plan if it won the federal election.

“The government remains committed to these proposals; this scheme was only shelved because it did not have enough support to guarantee passage of the legislation through the parliament,” said Simon Breheny, director of the IPA’s legal rights project.

He said the advice from Mr Callinan and Mr Conde indicated that well-drafted provisions were likely to be upheld by the High Court.

“Australians should be aware that we do not have robust constitutional protections for free speech. The Australian Constitution and the High Court cannot be relied on to protect us from restrictions on freedom of speech,” Mr Breheny said.

While the government has not explicitly ruled out a revised version of the Conroy plan, Kevin Rudd this week appeared to rule out changes to media laws affecting the circulation of newspapers.

Mr Rudd said Labor had “no such plans” to change media laws despite saying News Corp Australia — publisher of The Australian — owned about 70 per cent of metropolitan print circulation.

Before Senator Conroy‘s plan was withdrawn by the government, the media and communications committee of the Law Council had complained about the vague criteria governing the exercise of the PIMA’s proposed discretion.

Similar concerns were expressed by Liberty Victoria, the Queensland Council for Civil Liberties and the NSW Council for Civil Liberties.

Source: The Australian – Media regulator scheme ‘invalid’
 

About Craig Hill

Teacher and Writer. Writing has been cited in New York Times, BBC, Fox News, Aljazeera, Philippines Star, South China Morning Post, National Interest, news.com.au, Wikipedia and others.

Discussion

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

If you liked what you just read, click "Subscribe" to become a follower of the Craig Hill site. You will receive an email each time a new post is published.

Join 14,817 other followers

An archive of all my old posts

Follow me on Twitter

Most Recent Posts Post on My Blog About China: China News

US-China rivalry rooted in lost trust

US-China rivalry rooted in lost trust

As early as 2005 John Gersham and Melvin Goodman alerted against the trend of an over-militarized US foreign policy. The warning has been a recurrent theme of American debate, although it gained little traction. The debate recently spilled into mainstream media with The Economist averring that “an over-militarized foreign policy that embraces unrealistic objectives is liable to fail.” […]

Overnight News Headlines (Australia): July 20, 2021

Overnight News Headlines (Australia): July 20, 2021

Originally posted on Craig Hill:
Children account for 15 per cent of Australian farm deaths, says AgHealth study – 15 per cent of farm deaths are children under 14 years old, according to an AgHealth Australia study; A Ballarat farmer says she is shocked almost one in six … Australia’s first body image program for…

China in the News: July 20, 2021

China in the News: July 20, 2021

Ford unveils lower-priced Mustang Mach-E in China to qualify for subsidies – Previously, this was the only Mach-E priced low enough to qualify for China’s EV subsidies. It was joined by Extended Range RWD and AWD versions as well as the … NZ in ‘position of vulnerability’ over China hacking accusations – New Zealand has […]

Cadence Column: Asia, July 19, 2021

Cadence Column: Asia, July 19, 2021

China faces a three-pronged attack in the realm of public opinion. The Olympics converge with COVID; the third is three levelings up in Chinese military aggression. COVID is seen in the public eye as having mainly originated from China. Even with conspiracy theories surrounding Fauci and Gates, no explanation lets China off the hook. That […]

Overnight News Headlines (Australia): July 19, 2021

Overnight News Headlines (Australia): July 19, 2021

Originally posted on Craig Hill:
Race on for Australian rare earth supplies as fears grow over China’s market ‘monopoly’ – It comes two years after David Gainer, the US Consul General to Perth, visited a rare earths mine near Laverton in outback Western Australia just days into the … Swim league to be launched in…

China in the News: July 19, 2021

China in the News: July 19, 2021

First human death due to monkey B virus reported in China – Patients of rare viral infections transmitted from the monkey have been reported in China and the U.S. in succession. According to China’s state-run Global … Commentary: A pity China can’t seem to ditch its wolf warrior diplomacy – Despite recent exhortations from President […]

The Nuclear Future of East Asia

The Nuclear Future of East Asia

In the face of North Korea and China’s continuous expansion and advancement in their nuclear arsenal in the past decade, the nuclear question for East Asian countries is now more urgent than ever—especially when U.S.’s credibility of extended deterrence has been shrinking since the post-cold war era. Whether to acquire independent nuclear deterrent has long […]

Overnight News Headlines (Australia): July 18, 2021

Overnight News Headlines (Australia): July 18, 2021

Originally posted on Craig Hill:
New study reveals history of Aboriginal trade with foreign visitors before British settlement – They are markers of an annual Asian occupation of the northernmost tip of Western Australia that remains a mystery. “This is an unknown part of Australian … Lolesio kicks 14-man Australia to win to seal series…

China in the News: July 18, 2021

China in the News: July 18, 2021

China threat: Australia detects two Chinese spy ships ahead of a major US missile launch on Sunday – AUSTRALIA has detected “unusual” spy activity from Beijing after a second high-tech Chinese military ship was spotted approaching the Queensland coast ahead … Chinese in S. Korean entertainment industry face backlash – Some Chinese K-pop stars deemed […]

China targets overthrow of global order as expert warns of ‘brutal authoritarianism’ rise

China targets overthrow of global order as expert warns of ‘brutal authoritarianism’ rise

CHINA has set out to overthrow the global liberal system in favour of a more compatible “authoritarian” order, a former CIA officer has stated. The Chinese leadership has set out to replace the international rules bases order, a former US intelligence analyst has warned.  Nicholas Eftimiades, an expert on China, has warned that Xi Jinping‘s regime believes […]

%d bloggers like this: