you're reading...
Australian Current Affairs

Funding crisis for juvenile justice in Australia

Orana Juvenile Justice Centre, Dubbo, NSW, Australia

Orana Juvenile Justice Centre, Dubbo, NSW, Australia

The nation’s children’s court system is damaged, starved of resources and handing out sentences that vary widely depending on where children live.

The first national study of the country’s children’s courts, based on hundreds of interviews with magistrates, other judicial officers and a range of stakeholders, has called for an overhaul of the system.

The groundbreaking review found that the lack of specialist children’s court magistrates in many locations across Australia‘s eight jurisdictions was leading to vastly different sentences for the same crimes. The three-year study found that children in regional and remote communities were getting harsher sentences because of a lack of a specialist children’s magistrate in these areas.

The report makes a number of recommendations, including increasing the age of criminal responsibility from 10 to 12 years as recommended by the UN committee on the rights of the child, and a substantial investment in bail support programs so that children are not remanded in custody unnecessarily.

It also calls for the greater use of indigenous children’s courts and sentencing circles that rely on elders being involved in the sentencing process, after indigenous children were found to be receiving the harshest sentences.

The National Assessment of Australia’s Children’s Courts led by Allan Borowski from the Department of Social Work and Social Policy at La Trobe University, with Rosemary Sheehan from Monash University’s Department of Social Work was funded by an Australian Research Council discovery grant. The findings will be published in the Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology later this year.

The study finds the growing and increasingly complex workload confronting the children’s court system requires a major increase in court resources and funding.

It also highlights as a major problem the large number of generalists who preside over magistrates or local courts in regional and remote locations and then convene children’s courts.

“The mix of specialists and generalists was viewed by NSW, South Australian and Queensland study participants as problematic,” the report says.

Professor Borowski told The Australian that in regional, rural and remote locations, magistrates were generalists who spent most of their time dealing with adults.

“They are not specialists as in the major cities,” he said. “As a result, you can get a disparity in sentencing. In other words, there can be a certain harshness in sentencing.

“The same case heard before a specialist magistrate in the city would not result in as severe a sentence.

Aboriginal kids can often get harsher sentences. And bail is less likely to be made available to them. The issue of disparity in sentencing is geographic; we refer to it as postcode justice.

“Depending on where you live, the same case will have a different outcome.”

The study’s participants judicial officers, lawyers, youth justice workers and child protection workers in every state and territory – reported that relative to a decade ago, the court served a much more challenging clientele.

“What is new is the complexity of their problems and needs and, in Victoria and NSW, the increase in clients from a refugee background,” the report says.

“Alcohol and drug abuse, domestic violence, mental health problems and, indeed, prior involvement with the child protection system are now common among the clientele of the child protection jurisdiction.

“Young offenders manifest similar problems and have increasingly engaged in serious (violent) criminal activity. ACT study participants reported a growth in the number of young female offenders appearing in court.”

The report says there is profound concern about court facilities across all jurisdictions, with the exception of Tasmania.

Buildings were reported as failing to cater to children’s needs and described as “overcrowded, tense, chaotic and often unsafe and without adequate security”.

Interview rooms for lawyers to meet clients were either lacking or inadequate, while audio-visual systems to permit parents to participate in proceedings were either poor or not available. Holding facilities for remandees brought to court and those sentenced to detention were either inappropriate or inadequate, while facilities were seen as much worse in regional and remote locations.

The study says it is necessary to change towards a non-adversarial problem-solving approach, particularly in relation to child protection matters.

“Arguably the most significant theme that emerged was that of under-resourcing, not simply of the courts but also of Australia’s youth justice and child protection systems,” the report says.

The authors say “in the competition among public bureaucracies for resources, these courts and systems have not fared well.

“And while inadequate resources is a common refrain, in some jurisdictions it has placed the children’s court at very considerable risk of becoming meaningless in the absence of the instrumental means of achieving its mandates.

“The failure to invest adequately in this court and the youth justice and child protection systems will have major long-term detrimental consequences for Australia as a whole.”

Over the past five years, the lodgment rate for criminal matters in children’s courts increased markedly in NSW and moderately in the Northern Territory. Nationally, they currently finalise almost 67,000 criminal matters and 21,000 child welfare matters a year.

The report finds that child protection workers in some jurisdictions prepare for cases poorly and are unable to perform as witnesses in often vigorous adversarial court proceedings.

Some study participants suggested that CPWs involved in court work, such as judicial officers, should be required to have a specialist qualification.

The report finds that in Western Australia, the lack of resources outside Perth for children, young people and families, a higher proportion of whom are Aboriginal, is reported as so severe that the court is seen as a “sham” institution incapable of realising its purposes.

Source: The Australian “Funding crisis for juvenile justice”

About Craig Hill

Teacher and Writer. Writing has been cited in New York Times, BBC, Fox News, Aljazeera, Philippines Star, South China Morning Post, National Interest, news.com.au, Wikipedia and others.



  1. Pingback: New Zealand may take asylum-seekers from Australian detention « Craig Hill - February 8, 2013

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

If you liked what you just read, click "Subscribe" to become a follower of the Craig Hill site. You will receive an email each time a new post is published.

Join 14,835 other followers

An archive of all my old posts

Follow me on Twitter

Most Recent Posts Post on My Blog About China: China News

Cadence Column: Asia, August 2, 2021

Cadence Column: Asia, August 2, 2021

British aircraft carrier HMS Queen Elizabeth is trudging through China’s backyard. Chinese government news “Global Times” describes Britain as trying to relive its old days. China was never happy about getting its ass whipped twice in the Opium Wars, which China provoked with its economic philosophy that “sliver-in, tealeaves-out” was sustainable trade. China, now with […]

Attacks on foreign journalists in China cast shadow over Beijing’s upcoming Olympics

Attacks on foreign journalists in China cast shadow over Beijing’s upcoming Olympics

After promises during the 2008 Olympics, “[f]ew could have imagined the CCP stooping to the level of running campaigns against individual news reporters and outlets, resulting in harassment and death threats against foreign reporters,” writes William Nee. On July 20, in the central plains of Henan province, one of China’s most important regional cities, Zhengzhou, […]

Tibet and China clash over next reincarnation of the Dalai Lama

Tibet and China clash over next reincarnation of the Dalai Lama

A couple of years ago, during a meeting of Tibetan leaders in Dharamshala in India, Tenzin Gyatso, the 14th Dalai Lama, was asked about his reincarnation. Addressing the room of monks, religious teachers and Tibetan politicians, the Dalai Lama asked them to look into his eyes. “Do you think it’s time now?” he asked. It […]

China orders one member of each Tibetan family to enlist in the military to fight against India

China orders one member of each Tibetan family to enlist in the military to fight against India

China has been hatching several conspiracies since its defeat on the eastern Ladakh border against India last year. Considering the fact that Tibetan youth can play a vital role in fighting India in the Himalayan mountains on the borders of eastern Ladakh to Arunachal Pradesh, China has made it mandatory for one member of every […]

China warns UK as carrier strike group approaches South China Sea

China warns UK as carrier strike group approaches South China Sea

China has warned the UK’s Carrier Strike Group, led by the aircraft carrier HMS Queen Elizabeth not to carry out any “improper acts” as it enters the contested South China Sea. ‘The People’s Liberation Army Navy is at a high state of combat readiness’ says the pro-government Global Times, seen as a mouthpiece for the […]

China Has Reportedly Launched a Little Baby Version of the US X-37B Spaceplane

China Has Reportedly Launched a Little Baby Version of the US X-37B Spaceplane

A Chinese aerospace manufacturer hailed a successful test flight of a new spaceplane that will broaden China’s reusable spaceflight capabilities. The unnamed craft reportedly takes off like a rocket and lands like an airplane, much like the U.S. Air Force’s X-37B (pictured above), but can’t go all the way into orbit like the American spaceplane […]

China Discovers the Limits of Its Power

China Discovers the Limits of Its Power

Beijing’s confrontation with Australia should have been an unequal contest. That’s not how it worked out in practice. “Chewing gum stuck on the sole of China’s shoes.” That’s how Hu Xijin, the editor of the Chinese Communist Party–run Global Times, described Australia last year. The disparaging description is typical of the disdain that China’s diplomats […]

China looking at expropriating foreign-held tech shares

Those foreigners who hold shares in Chinese tech companies are being warned that all is not well. It is China expert Gordon Chang who explained at Gatestone Institute, where he is a distinguished senior fellow and a member of the advisory board, that the nation controlled by a repressive Communist regime is “on the road […]

Cadence Column: Asia, July 26, 2021

Cadence Column: Asia, July 26, 2021

While a typhoon largely evaded Taiwan over the weekend, tragedy struck the mainland. Shanghai faced flooding and death while India suffered a landslide in the Himalayas. In a shocking video, one boulder took out a bridge. Several people died. But, speaking of Taiwan’s tendency to fall out of manure smelling like roses, there’s nothing like […]

On This Day In Australia: In 1950, Australia announced they would send troops to the Korean War

On This Day In Australia: In 1950, Australia announced they would send troops to the Korean War

Originally posted on Craig Hill:
Third Royal Australian Regiment Only five years after the end of the Second World War, Australia became involved in the Korean War. Personnel from the Royal Australian Navy (RAN), Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF), and the Australian Regular Army (ARA) were committed soon after the war began and would serve…

%d bloggers like this: