you're reading...
Australian Current Affairs

Bad teaching in Australian schools causes low literacy rates

Australian primary school students practice reading

Australian primary school students practice reading

In his 1955 book Why Johnny Can’t Read, Rudolph Flesch explained that quality of instruction was the key to improving children’s literacy. Almost 60 years later, children’s names may have changed but the story remains the same.

Billions of dollars have been spent in the past decade on programs aimed at improving literacy, yet thousands of children still struggle with basic reading skills.

In the 2013 National Assessment Program for Literacy and Numeracy 11.5 per cent of Year 3 students achieved only the (very low) minimum standard for reading, or below it.

This means 32,000 cognitively-able children, the equivalent of 100 primary schools, are still poor readers after four years of school and 1200 hours of reading instruction. There are thousands more non-readers in the higher grades.

The problem of low literacy is not one of funding and it is not intractable. The problem is an entrenched gap between research and practice. Despite robust scientific research on how children acquire reading skills early and quickly, too many children are not receiving effective, evidence-based reading instruction. Five essential skills are necessary for proficient and engaged reading: phonemic awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary and comprehension.

The so-called “reading wars” are portrayed as an academic debate over phonics, which teaches children the alphabetic code, versus a whole-language approach, which encourages development of higher-order literacy skills. This is a false dichotomy. Reading researchers do not claim phonics is a complete approach to reading instruction.

Phonics is one essential part of a high-quality comprehensive reading program. It has been the focus of particular attention because it is the component most often neglected or poorly taught. High-quality phonics instruction is explicit, systematic and structured. Pointing out letter sounds during shared reading activities is not phonics instruction.

Why are children not receiving effective evidence-based reading instruction, including phonics?

First, many teachers do not have the adequate literacy skills for teaching reading effectively. Studies of trainee and practising teachers in Australia (and in the US and Britain) have repeatedly shown a large proportion of teachers have insufficient knowledge of meta-linguistics-basic language constructs such as morphology and phonological awareness – to be able to use it in their teaching.

For example, only 38 per cent of pre-service teachers and 52 per cent of in-service teachers in a Victorian study knew the definition of “syllable”.

Second, teacher education degrees have not adequately prepared teachers in effective reading instruction. The National Inquiry into the Teaching of Literacy in 2005 found less than 10 per cent of time in compulsory units of primary teaching degrees was devoted to reading instruction.

Subsequent surveys and inquiries indicate not much has changed. The little time that is spent on reading in teacher education courses is weighted towards theories of literacy, especially whole-language philosophies, rather than proven, effective practice.

The major influences on teaching methods in schools are the university education faculties that produce teachers and the government education departments that produce literacy policies and programs.

There appears to be an ideological hegemony among these two agencies of influence that actively or passively works against implementing effective evidence-based reading instruction.

For some people there is a vested or professional interest in preserving the whole-language status quo, while for others whole-language philosophies are inseparable from a broader economic and political ideology.

Another key factor is that scientific techniques are not privileged in education research, practice or policy. Few teacher education courses provide teachers with the statistical skills to evaluate and interpret data or to critically appraise research. Attitudes to scientific studies in education research and policy-making vary from disdain to indifference.

The problems in educational academe might be mitigated if government policies and programs were rigorous. Unfortunately, policy is often based on flawed information from people without expertise in the highly specific, scientific disciplines of initial and remedial reading research.

Literacy policy has been consistently undermined by the vagaries of the political cycle, a reliance on non-expert “experts”, and misallocation of resources into ineffective programs, partly because of a failure to evaluate programs properly.

Jennifer Buckingham is a research fellow at the Centre for Independent Studies and co-author of “Why Jaydon can’t read: The triumph of ideology over evidence in teaching reading” in the spring edition of Policy Magazine
Source: The Australian – Bad teaching kills reading skills

About Craig Hill

Teacher and Writer. Writing has been cited in New York Times, BBC, Fox News, Aljazeera, Philippines Star, South China Morning Post, National Interest, news.com.au, Wikipedia and others.


No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

If you liked what you just read, click "Subscribe" to become a follower of the Craig Hill site. You will receive an email each time a new post is published.

Join 14,948 other followers

An archive of all my old posts

Follow me on Twitter

Most Recent Posts Post on My Blog About China: China News

The vanishing allure of doing business in China

The vanishing allure of doing business in China

It is nothing new for foreign firms to endure shakedowns by the Chinese Communist Party. As far back as revolutionary times, Chairman Mao’s victorious troops did not directly confiscate foreign-owned assets as their Bolshevik forerunners had done in Russia. Instead, they wore them down with higher taxes and fines so big that eventually companies gave […]

Wikipedia blames pro-China infiltration for bans

Wikipedia blames pro-China infiltration for bans

Wikipedia has suffered an “infiltration” that sought to advance the aims of China, the US non-profit organisation that owns the volunteer-edited encyclopaedia has said. The Wikimedia Foundation told BBC News the infiltration had threatened the “very foundations of Wikipedia”. The foundation banned seven editors linked to a mainland China group. Wikimedians of Mainland China accused […]

Diaries of former Mao aide spark custody battle over unofficial history of China

Diaries of former Mao aide spark custody battle over unofficial history of China

Today, “Li materials” are the subject of a legal battle between Stanford University and Mr. Li’s widow in Beijing. This is a battle for custody of an unofficial history of China. In millions of handwritten Chinese characters, Mr. Li documents his early days in the party, the revolution that brought him to power and his […]

World’s dirtiest cities list raises issue: Why don’t politicians call out China?

World’s dirtiest cities list raises issue: Why don’t politicians call out China?

Ponder this: A new tally of global cities’ emissions finds that the top 25 are responsible for 52% of the planet’s urban greenhouse gas emissions. Twenty-three of those are in China. New York City is the first American city to appear, at No. 26. Out of the top 75, just four other American cities are listed […]

Cadence Column: Asia, September 13, 2021

Cadence Column: Asia, September 13, 2021

The easiest solution to China’s escalating situation in the South Sea is to enforce China’s own formal statements at face value. China says they respect other countries and do not want to militarize the South Sea. Leave it at that. Any disrespect toward other countries is not at the behest of Xijinping. Any militarization of […]

Why is Iran so keen on joining the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation?

Why is Iran so keen on joining the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation?

What Happened: Iran became an observer in the Shanghai Cooperation Organization – originally comprised of China, Russia, and 4 Central Asian republics – back in 2005. In the 16 years since, Tehran has consistently pushed for an upgrade to full membership, particularly after the SCO underwent its first expansion, adding India and Pakistan, in 2017. […]

How China hijacked the war on terror to commit genocide in Xinjiang

How China hijacked the war on terror to commit genocide in Xinjiang

Two decades after the 9/11 attacks spawned the U.S. government’s self-declared “Global War on Terrorism,” the nation that responded to it with the most aggressive regulatory, policing and social policies is thousands of miles from Ground Zero. China’s ruling Chinese Communist Party exploited the international revulsion toward terrorism sparked by the 9/11 attacks to reframe […]

China extends a fast helping hand to the Taliban

China extends a fast helping hand to the Taliban

China has reassured the Taliban that it is ready to begin development activities in Afghanistan via its ambitious multi-trillion-dollar Belt and Road initiative (BRI), as the war-torn country drifts toward an economic meltdown. In what some see as Beijing’s tacit approval of the Afghan militant group’s interim government, China announced on Wednesday (September 8) US$31 […]

China’s population enters ‘deep aging’ in many major cities

China’s population enters ‘deep aging’ in many major cities

China is facing a population crisis of increasing urgency, with 149 cities shown in recent census figures to have 14 percent of their residents over the age of 65. A recent analysis by the state-run China Business News (CBN) found that 149 cities in China have now entered “deep aging,” the middle state on a […]

China weighing occupation of former U.S. air base at Bagram in Afghanistan

China weighing occupation of former U.S. air base at Bagram in Afghanistan

China is considering deploying military personnel and economic development officials to Bagram airfield, perhaps the single-most prominent symbol of the 20-year U.S. military presence in Afghanistan.  The Chinese military is currently conducting a feasibility study about the effect of sending workers, soldiers and other staff related to its foreign economic investment program known as the […]

%d bloggers like this: